STHO
BuyBargain BinAI neutralStar Holdings · Real Estate · United States · $91M cap · $479K/day traded
$7.81 +0.0% · close 4 Nov · scored 5 Nov
StockRank down 3.6 since 4 Nov: Momentum down 4.
Bargain Bin: Looks like a bargain; the quality and the trend say why it is in the bin.
As of 5 Nov 2026, MoatMap's StockRank for Star Holdings (STHO) is 67/100, ranked against 24,000+ stocks in 35 markets (Quality 48, Value 74, Momentum 40, each scored against its sector).
Does StockRank work? Each month we publish how each tenth of the ranking did, whichever way it went. See the record →
Star Holdings was spun off from iStar to own and sell off legacy real estate, land and loans, including the Asbury Park development, with a small buyback in place. Its value depends on how well those assets are sold over time rather than on a growing business, and there is limited visibility on sale prices.
ABOUT STAR HOLDINGS
Read
Star Holdings engages in the non-ground lease real estate assets business in the United States. The company portfolio comprises Asbury Park Waterfront and Magnolia Green residential development projects.
FINANCIAL SUMMARY (USD)
| Year | 2022 | 2023 | 2024 | 2025 | CAGR | TTM |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Revenue | 96.1M | 101.2M | 88.9M | 75.7M | -7.7% | 98.3M |
| EPS | -2.73 | -14.74 | -6.51 | -4.90 | — | 1.22 |
| Shares | 13.3M | 13.3M | 13.3M | 12.3M | -7.5% | 12.1M |
| Debt | 2.0M | 194.4M | 218.4M | 269.4M | 412.1% | 209.2M |
| Equity | 971.5M | 411.6M | 324.3M | 251.8M | -36.2% | — |
| Op CF | -27.4M | -18.7M | -31.3M | -11.7M | — | -13.9M |
| Inv CF | 236.1M | 186.0M | 0.3M | -1.5M | — | — |
| Fin CF | -218.3M | -114.1M | 15.8M | 34.8M | — | — |
No clear trend: not near its 52-week low, and not in a steady uptrend.
Calmer than 71% of stocks we rank over the past year (volatility 31% a year).
How this is worked out
StockRank weighs the business, its price and its trend. The price check reads only the chart: the price side of the Momentum score, in words.
The rules: Still falling is a new 52-week low in the last two weeks, at least 25% below the high. Finding a floor is no new low since. Turning up is 20 or more trading days without a new low, at least 10% off it, and back above a rising 50-day average. In an uptrend is above the 200-day average and within 15% of the high.
In 2,112 US drawdowns since 2001, buying while the price was still falling was followed by a further 20% drop 42% of the time. Waiting for a turn (the Turning up rule above) cut that to 33%, at about 7% higher prices and with no better returns. Part of that cut is simply not buying: 13% of falls never turned, and waiting kept those out. Among turns that were bought, 38% still fell another 20%, and 33% of turns were followed by a new low within six months. The benefit was largest in crashes such as 2008 and 2020.
What it measures: how much the price moved day to day over the past year, scaled to a yearly figure (annualised volatility) and ranked against every stock we cover. Very calm under 20% a year, Calm 20 to 30%, Average 30 to 40%, Bumpy 40 to 55%, Very bumpy above that.
What we found: across about 13,500 stocks in 34 markets (2002 to 2025), past swings were a good guide to the next year's, and bumpier stocks fell further. How much further changed too much between eras to put a number on it.
Calm is not safe: a calm stock can still slide steadily.
Rules fixed before any data was fetched. Describes the chart, not a recommendation.
SCORE BREAKDOWN
FUNDAMENTALS
SECTOR PEERS
Closest peers in Real Estate, ranked by industry match, size, and score similarity. Cross-listings of STHO are excluded.
| Ticker | Company | Mkt Cap | StockRank | Signal |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| STHO | Star Holdings(you) | $91M | 67 | Buy |
| DOUG | Douglas Elliman Inc. | $145M | 35 | Hold |
| CHCI | Comstock Holding Companies, Inc. | $179M | 98 | Strong Buy |
| MAYS | J.W. Mays, Inc. | $83M | 21 | Sell |
| RMR | The RMR Group Inc. | $299M | 93 | Strong Buy |
| ARL | American Realty Investors, Inc. | $239M | 37 | Hold |
| SRG | Seritage Growth Properties | $91M | 13 | Strong Sell |
| SEG | Seaport Entertainment Group Inc. | $291M | 29 | Sell |
| MMI | Marcus & Millichap, Inc. | $1.0B | 51 | Hold |
| TCI | Transcontinental Realty Investors, Inc. | $425M | 33 | Sell |
Peer medians: ROE 4.2% · P/E 23.9x · Gross margin 66.0%
Company Deep Dive
A 10,000-word report: the business and its segments, what management promised on earnings calls and whether it delivered, the competition, and how things could turn out.