Company Deep Dive

Business segments breakdown, earnings transcript analysis, management credibility scoring, competitive landscape, and scenario modelling.

Request Deep Dive(50 Feathers)

ACIC

HOLDFLAG

American Coastal Insurance Corporation · Financial Services · United States · $498M · Avg Vol: $3M/d

63
StockRank
Get insider-trade alerts
Q
70
V
70
M
17
P/E (TTM)
4.8x
ROE
35.9%
D/E
0.5x
Dividend %
AI CONVICTION THESIS

American Coastal Insurance has strong quality Q70 and value V68 with a buyback, but momentum at M34 is well below the calibrated floor, and a positive revision is not accepted corroboration, so stage one fails.

COMPANY DESCRIPTION

American Coastal Insurance Corporation underwrites and sells property and casualty insurance, primarily specializing in residential property coverage for high-value homes in Florida. The company navigates the challenging Florida insurance market by leveraging localized expertise, stringent underwriting, and robust reinsurance programs to manage catastrophe exposure. ACIC operates as a niche player focused on this specific, often volatile, regional market segment.

FINANCIAL SUMMARY (USD)

Year2022202320242025CAGRTTM2026E2027EFwd CAGR
Revenue220.8M263.7M296.4M335.0M14.9%334.5M309.9M325.8M-1.4%
EPS-10.917.111.592.20-44.4%2.141.121.64-13.7%
Shares43.3M46.8M48.2M48.8M+12.7%48.5M
Debt150.0M149.4M152.3M152.5M0.5%152.5M
Equity-182.0M168.8M235.7M317.6M37.2%
Op CF-173.1M-136.0M243.5M71.0M-70.8%38.8M
Inv CF236.8M-2.5M-179.2M0.6M
Fin CF-25.4M26.8M-13.8M-1.1M
Loading 1Y...
PRICE (1Y)-1.5%
9.9410.3510.7511.1611.57Jun 11Jul 6Jul 24
SMA 50SMA 200
Close
$10.28
RSI (14)
30.8
52W High
$12.30
From 52W High
0.8%

SCORE BREAKDOWN

Quality
70
ROIC (ROA)
8.6%*82.8
ROE
35.9%95.8
GP/Assets
18.0%85.2
Op. Margin
39.2%58.0
FCF/Assets
6.6%82.3
Piotroski
444.0
Int. Cover
14.2x57.4
D/E Ratio
0.46x45.3
Current Ratio
1.07x32.5
Value
70
P/E (TTM)
4.8x92.5
EV/EBITDA
3.3x83.9
P/FCF
7.0x71.4
P/B
1.5x34.9
P/S
1.5x82.6
Div Yield
N/A
Momentum
17
52W High %
84%28.8
RS 6M
-16%20.4
SMA 50/200
0.96x20.3
EPS Rev 4W
-15.4%1.9
EPS Rev 12W
-34.3%1.8
EPS Improve
-53%5.2
Q Growth
-10%21.1

FUNDAMENTALS

Market Cap
$498M
P/E (Forward)
10.2x
Gross Margin
57.6%

SECTOR PEERS

Closest peers in Financial Services, ranked by industry match, size, and score similarity. Cross-listings of ACIC are excluded.

TickerCompanyMkt CapStockRankSignal
ACICAmerican Coastal Insurance Corporation(you)$498M63HOLD
GBLIGlobal Indemnity Group, LLC$394M61HOLD
DGICBDonegal Group Inc.$773M55HOLD
ROOTRoot, Inc.$917M53HOLD
NODKNI Holdings, Inc.$325M49HOLD
HIPOHippo Holdings Inc.$723M48HOLD
AIIAmerican Integrity Insurance Group, Inc.$366M86STRONG BUY
ASICAtegrity Specialty Insurance Company Holdings$1.1B77BUY
BOWBowhead Specialty Holdings Inc.$1.0B81STRONG BUY
STCStewart Information Services Corporation$2.1B69BUY

Peer medians: ROE 9.4% · P/E 13.9x · Gross margin 100.0%

American Coastal Insurance Corporation (ACIC) — Stock Score Summary

American Coastal Insurance Corporation (ACIC) has a MoatMap StockRank of 63/100 based on Quality (70/100), Value (70/100), and Momentum (17/100) factor scores. The current signal is HOLD. American Coastal Insurance has strong quality Q70 and value V68 with a buyback, but momentum at M34 is well below the calibrated floor, and a positive revision is not accepted corroboration, so stage one fails.

American Coastal Insurance Corporation underwrites and sells property and casualty insurance, primarily specializing in residential property coverage for high-value homes in Florida. The company navigates the challenging Florida insurance market by leveraging localized expertise, stringent underwriting, and robust reinsurance programs to manage catastrophe exposure. ACIC operates as a niche player focused on this specific, often volatile, regional market segment.

Key Financial Metrics

Price$10.28
Market Cap$498M
P/E (TTM)4.82
P/E (Forward)10.16
Price/Book1.48
Return on Equity35.9%
Debt/Equity0.46x
Gross Margin57.6%
Operating Margin39.2%
Revenue Growth-1.4%
Free Cash Flow$71M

American Coastal Insurance Corporation operates in the Insurance - Property & Casualty industry, part of the Financial Services sector (United States).

Frequently Asked Questions

What is American Coastal Insurance Corporation’s (ACIC) StockRank?
MoatMap’s StockRank for American Coastal Insurance Corporation (ACIC) is 63/100, with a Hold signal. It is a composite of Quality (70), Value (70), and Momentum (17) factor ranks across MoatMap’s 20,000+ stock universe.
Does American Coastal Insurance Corporation have an economic moat?
American Coastal Insurance Corporation (ACIC) has a Quality factor score of 70/100. The Quality factor combines ROIC, Piotroski F-Score, and leverage — the financial fingerprints of a durable competitive advantage. A Quality score above 70 typically indicates a company with the characteristics of a moated business.
Is American Coastal Insurance Corporation a buy, hold, or sell?
MoatMap’s current signal for American Coastal Insurance Corporation (ACIC) is Hold, based on a StockRank of 63/100. Signals are derived mechanically from the StockRank composite and should be one input among many — combine with your own thesis on management, competitive position, and valuation.
What sector is American Coastal Insurance Corporation in?
American Coastal Insurance Corporation (ACIC) operates in the Financial Services sector, specifically the Insurance - Property & Casualty industry (United States).