What is American Financial Group, Inc.'s (AFG) StockRank?

MoatMap's StockRank for American Financial Group, Inc. (AFG) is 63/100, with a Hold signal. This is a composite score combining Quality (54), Value (37), and Momentum (66) factor ranks across MoatMap's 20,000+ stock universe.

Does American Financial Group, Inc. have an economic moat?

American Financial Group, Inc. (AFG) has a Quality factor score of 54/100. The Quality factor combines ROIC, Piotroski F-Score, and leverage — the financial fingerprints of a durable competitive advantage. A Quality score above 70 typically indicates a company with the financial characteristics of a moated business.

Is American Financial Group, Inc. a buy, hold, or sell?

MoatMap's current signal for American Financial Group, Inc. (AFG) is Hold, based on a StockRank of 63/100. Signals are derived mechanically from the StockRank composite and should be one input among many — combine with your own thesis on management, competitive position, and valuation.

What sector is American Financial Group, Inc. in?

American Financial Group, Inc. (AFG) operates in the Financial Services sector, specifically the Insurance - Property & Casualty industry (United States).

Company Deep Dive

Business segments breakdown, earnings transcript analysis, management credibility scoring, competitive landscape, and scenario modelling.

Request Deep Dive(50 Feathers)

AFG

HOLD

American Financial Group, Inc. · Financial Services · United States · $11.9B · Avg Vol: $76M/d

StockRank

Get insider-trade alerts

P/E (TTM)

13.5x

ROE

19.4%

D/E

0.4x

Dividend %

2.4%

COMPANY DESCRIPTION

American Financial Group, Inc. is an insurance holding company primarily engaged in property and casualty (P&C) insurance, with a specialized focus on niche commercial lines and annuities. The company's competitive moat stems from its disciplined underwriting expertise, diversified portfolio of specialty P&C businesses that are less susceptible to commoditization, and conservative investment strategy. American Financial Group is a well-regarded specialty insurer, consistently generating strong returns through its focused market approach and strong financial management.

FINANCIAL SUMMARY (USD)

Year	2022	2023	2024	2025	CAGR	TTM	2026E	2027E	Fwd CAGR
Revenue	6.8B	7.7B	8.3B	8.1B	6.2%	7.9B	8.3B	8.8B	4.0%
EPS	10.54	10.19	10.56	10.09	-1.4%	10.56	11.38	11.83	8.3%
Shares	85.2M	83.6M	84.0M	83.4M	-2.1%	83.1M	—	—	—
Debt	1.5B	1.5B	1.5B	1.8B	6.8%	2.0B	—	—	—
Equity	4.1B	4.3B	4.5B	4.8B	6.0%	—	—	—	—
Op CF	1.2B	2.0B	1.2B	1.5B	10.0%	1.7B	—	—	—
Inv CF	-1.1B	414.0M	95.0M	-835.0M	—	—	—	—	—
Fin CF	-1.4B	-2.0B	-1.1B	-377.0M	—	—	—	—	—

Loading 1Y...

PRICE (1Y)+7.3%

SMA 50SMA 200

$143.88

RSI (14)

56.6

52W High

$145.00

From 52W High

1.0%

SCORE BREAKDOWN

Quality

ROIC (ROA)

2.5%*60.3

ROE

19.4%84.6

GP/Assets

4.7%55.4

Op. Margin

14.6%33.6

FCF/Assets

0.9%37.0

Piotroski

444.0

Int. Cover

14.4x57.9

D/E Ratio

0.44x47.1

Current Ratio

2.15x60.0

Value

P/E (TTM)

13.5x48.2

EV/EBITDA

9.4x46.2

P/FCF

39.8x11.8

P/B

2.5x17.5

P/S

1.5x82.7

Div Yield

2.4%28.7

Momentum

52W High %

99%91.9

RS 6M

7%69.8

SMA 50/200

1.04x54.0

EPS Rev 4W

-0.1%62.7

EPS Rev 12W

+0.3%59.8

EPS Improve

+14%38.8

Q Growth

24%58.2

FUNDAMENTALS

Market Cap

$11.9B

P/E (Forward)

11.8x

Gross Margin

19.3%

SECTOR PEERS

Closest peers in Financial Services, ranked by industry match, size, and score similarity. Cross-listings of AFG are excluded.

Ticker	Company	Mkt Cap	StockRank	Signal
AFG	American Financial Group, Inc.(you)	$11.9B	63	HOLD
L	Loews Corporation	$24.3B	68	BUY
RLI	RLI Corp.	$5.7B	55	HOLD
HGTY	Hagerty, Inc.	$4.0B	61	HOLD
CNA	CNA Financial Corporation	$14.5B	84	STRONG BUY
KNSL	Kinsale Capital Group, Inc.	$8.0B	47	HOLD
WRB	W. R. Berkley Corporation	$28.0B	72	BUY
AIZ	Assurant, Inc.	$13.7B	87	STRONG BUY
ORI	Old Republic International Corporation	$10.3B	89	STRONG BUY
PLMR	Palomar Holdings, Inc.	$3.6B	68	BUY

Peer medians: ROE 9.4% · P/E 13.9x · Gross margin 100.0%

American Financial Group, Inc. (AFG) — Stock Score Summary

American Financial Group, Inc. (AFG) has a MoatMap StockRank of 63/100 based on Quality (54/100), Value (37/100), and Momentum (66/100) factor scores. The current signal is HOLD.

Key Financial Metrics

Price	$143.88
Market Cap	$11.9B
P/E (TTM)	13.47
P/E (Forward)	11.80
Price/Book	2.53
Return on Equity	19.4%
Debt/Equity	0.44x
Gross Margin	19.3%
Operating Margin	14.6%
Revenue Growth	0.3%
Dividend Yield	2.4%
Free Cash Flow	$300M

American Financial Group, Inc. operates in the Insurance - Property & Casualty industry, part of the Financial Services sector (United States).

Frequently Asked Questions

What is American Financial Group, Inc.’s (AFG) StockRank?: MoatMap’s StockRank for American Financial Group, Inc. (AFG) is 63/100, with a Hold signal. It is a composite of Quality (54), Value (37), and Momentum (66) factor ranks across MoatMap’s 20,000+ stock universe.
Does American Financial Group, Inc. have an economic moat?: American Financial Group, Inc. (AFG) has a Quality factor score of 54/100. The Quality factor combines ROIC, Piotroski F-Score, and leverage — the financial fingerprints of a durable competitive advantage. A Quality score above 70 typically indicates a company with the characteristics of a moated business.
Is American Financial Group, Inc. a buy, hold, or sell?: MoatMap’s current signal for American Financial Group, Inc. (AFG) is Hold, based on a StockRank of 63/100. Signals are derived mechanically from the StockRank composite and should be one input among many — combine with your own thesis on management, competitive position, and valuation.
What sector is American Financial Group, Inc. in?: American Financial Group, Inc. (AFG) operates in the Financial Services sector, specifically the Insurance - Property & Casualty industry (United States).